Hiring a locksmith may seem straightforward at first. But rushing the choice often leads to regret. Many homeowners trust the first name they see, skip research, or overlook important details. Reports of rogue locksmiths increased by 25% in 2025, according to the Master Locksmith Association in the UK, with 350 complaints made that year.
This shows how common scams have become and why choosing the right professional matters more than ever. Even basic oversights, like skipping a license check or trusting a lowball quote, can cost you more in the long run.
That’s when problems start. You could get someone unlicensed, overpriced, or careless with your locks. Some rush through the job, and others add hidden fees. This guide covers 15 hiring mistakes you can easily avoid. Make smart choices and protect your home and wallet.
Top Mistakes People Make When Hiring a Locksmith
Hiring a locksmith without conducting proper checks can result in wasted money, subpar results, or even safety risks. Many of these mistakes are easy to avoid once you know what to watch for. Here are the most common mistakes homeowners make, along with tips on how to prevent them.
Picking the First Option
In an emergency, calling the first locksmith you see is the fastest solution. But not all locksmiths are trained, insured, or honest. A rushed decision could lead to poor work or unexpected extra costs. Before you let anyone work on your locks, take a moment to check reviews or ask for a referral. A quick look now can save you time, money, and stress later. Don’t forget to ask about experience with modern systems, such as keypads or smart lock technology, which are now common in 2025.
Not Hiring the Top Company
Choosing the wrong locksmith can lead to delays, poor results, or even damage to your property. Some individuals may lack the necessary training or tools to perform the job correctly the first time. That’s why it’s helpful to verify credentials, inquire about past work, and read reviews before making a decision. A trusted company brings skill, speed, and peace of mind. It saves you time and trouble in the long run.
Not All Locksmiths Match
Some locksmiths arrive late, overcharge, or fail to complete the job correctly. Others might not show up at all. That’s why you shouldn’t trust just anyone. Ask people you know for referrals, verify a working phone number, and confirm the company has a legitimate address. A little research helps you avoid stress and find someone who will do the job properly.
Skipping the Research
Hiring without first checking can lead to poor service or additional fees. A quick online search can show reviews, pricing, license details, and business hours. Look for clear contact info and check if they serve your area. Verified listings with photos and strong ratings usually mean reliable service. Taking a few minutes to research helps you avoid surprises and find a locksmith you can trust. Use Google Street View to verify that the business is located at the listed address.
Judging Too Quickly
A good first impression doesn’t always mean reliable service. Some locksmiths may seem helpful, but they often fail to follow through. Try calling back with a question or checking how they handle follow-ups. A dependable company will be clear, respectful, and ready to help beyond the first call. How they treat you after that first contact tells you more than any quick quote or friendly greeting.
Ignoring the Website
Not checking the locksmith’s website before calling can lead to wasted time or poor service. A missing service list, unclear pricing, or outdated contact information often signals a lack of professionalism. Look for clear business hours, customer reviews, and license details. A well-organized site shows the company takes its work seriously. It also helps you know what to expect before booking, saving you from surprises or hidden fees later. Also, check if they mention smart locks or high-security systems. Many homeowners are upgrading in 2025.
Skipping the Reviews
Overlooking customer reviews can lead to poor results. Yelp shows real stories from people who hired the locksmith you’re considering. Read a few reviews to spot clear patterns, whether positive or negative. Pay attention to how the company replies to complaints. Do they stay polite and offer help? That shows they care about service, not just sales. Checking reviews helps you avoid risky hires and choose someone with a strong track record in your area.
Overlooking the License
A license indicates that the locksmith has received proper training and follows state regulations for performing the job safely. It also proves the business is real and meets legal standards. Unlicensed locksmiths may cut corners or cause damage you’ll have to fix later.
They often lack insurance, leaving you at risk if something goes wrong. Before hiring, ask for proof of their license. It’s a quick way to protect your home and avoid unsafe or unskilled work. In states like Florida, operating without a permit can lead to fines and void any liability if something goes wrong.
Skipping Experience
Experience makes a big difference in locksmith work. Skilled pros finish faster, avoid damage, and handle tough jobs without guessing. Inexperienced ones may use the wrong tools or cause costly mistakes.
Before hiring, ask how long they’ve been in business and what types of locks they handle. You can also check for certifications or customer reviews. A well-trained locksmith saves you time, protects your property, and gets the job done right the first time.
Skipping References
References can tell you a great deal about how a locksmith operates. They help you learn if the job was done on time, handled with care, and priced fairly. Ask for one or two recent customers you can contact. A trusted company will have no problem sharing them. It’s a quick step that provides real feedback and helps you choose someone who has already proven they can do the job right.
Not Asking About Hours
Getting locked out late at night can be stressful and unsafe. Not every locksmith is available outside normal hours, so it’s important to ask if they offer 24/7 service. Whether it’s your home, car, or business, knowing someone can help anytime gives you peace of mind. Before hiring, verify their availability and ensure they’re prepared to respond when you need them most. It’s a small step that can save you from big problems later.
Missing Hidden Fees
Price surprises can happen if you don’t ask the right questions. Some locksmiths add extra charges for parts, fuel, or travel. In January 2025 alone, there were nearly 30 reports of rogue locksmiths overcharging customers, with some victims charged over £1,000 for simple lockout services and one case reaching £1,800.
Many were initially quoted £49–89 but faced much higher final bills. Always request a detailed cost breakdown before the job begins. A trusted company will provide you with a clear answer and adhere to it. If they can’t give an exact number, ask for a price range. Try to get it confirmed in writing. This simple step protects you from unexpected fees in the future. Beware of bait pricing like “$19 service call” ads. These often balloon into $200 or more once the technician arrives.
Not Getting a Warranty
A warranty shows that the locksmith stands behind their work. Without one, you may end up paying again if something goes wrong later. Ask if parts and labor are covered and how long the warranty lasts. Some companies only cover specific services, so be sure to read the details carefully.
A solid warranty means better protection and peace of mind. It also shows the locksmith takes pride in doing the job right the first time. In 2025, many reputable locksmiths offer guarantees ranging from 30 to 90 days. Ask before you agree to service.
Choosing the Right Locksmith Without Breaking the Bank
Avoiding hiring mistakes also means knowing how to spot real value. Many Riverview residents want reliable locksmith service without paying too much. The good news is, quality doesn’t have to come with a high price tag. From checking certifications to comparing service scopes, a smart approach can help you save while still getting dependable help. For a full breakdown on how to find a trustworthy locksmith that fits your budget, check out our detailed guide on How to Choose a Riverview Locksmith That Delivers Quality on a Budget.
Make the Right Choice for Security in Riverview with A1 Locksmith Services LLC
Avoiding hiring mistakes starts with choosing a locksmith you can trust. A1 Locksmith Services LLC serves Riverview with licensed, experienced professionals who show up on time, provide honest pricing, and stand behind their work with a solid warranty. Let us help you stay protected and stress-free from the very first call at +1 (813) 817-5576 .
